The Influence of Obesity on the Association of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Atrial Fibrillation
Article information
Abstract
Background and Objective
The association between obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and atrial fibrillation (AF) has been closely studied. However, obesity is a powerful confounder in the causal relationship between OSA and cardiovascular disease. The contribution of obesity in the relationship between OSA and AF remains unclear.
Methods
We recruited 457 consecutive patients equally with and without AF who underwent clinically indicated diagnostic polysomnography at a single academic sleep center. Multivariable logistic regression adjusting for age, sex, hypertension, and heart failure was performed to study the independent association between OSA and AF stratified by obesity.
Results
A total of 457 patients (male: 56.2%, mean age 63.1 ± 13.3 years) was included. OSA prevalence was similar between those with and without AF (52.6% vs. 47.4%, respectively; p = 0.24). In multivariable analysis, no association was found between AF and OSA regardless of obesity status. When severe OSA (vs. non-severe OSA) was modeled as a dependent variable, AF was associated with a higher likelihood of severe OSA in non-obese patients [odds ratio (OR): 2.29, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.23–4.35, p = 0.01], but not in obese patients (OR: 0.95, 95% CI: 0.48–1.90, p = 0.89).
Conclusions
The association of OSA with AF was present only in the non-obese and was limited to severe OSA patients. In contrast, no association was found in obese patients. The association between OSA and AF is partly dependent on the body habitus.
INTRODUCTION
Atrial fibrillation (AF) is the most common chronic cardiac dysrhythmia, and is associated with poor quality of life as well as increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality [1]. Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is the most common form of sleep-disordered breathing, and has previously been associated with adverse cardiovascular outcomes, including hypertension, ischemic heart disease, heart failure (HF), arrhythmias, and sudden cardiac death [2-10]. OSA is prevalent in the general adult population affecting at least 10–20% for males and 3–10% for females [11]. An increasing number of studies have implicated OSA as an important risk factor for AF [12-16]. However, delineating an independent association between OSA and AF is challenging, especially given their multiple shared risk factors, such as metabolic syndrome, age, obesity, and hypertension [17].
Of these mutual risk factors, obesity is particularly important as it is one of the most commonly shared risk factors for both OSA and AF. A clearer understanding of the relationship between these two conditions is particularly vital given that OSA and obesity are potentially modifiable risk factors for AF [18-20]. Notably, studies examining the association between OSA and AF have produced inconsistent outcomes, potentially due to differences in the distribution of obesity among study populations and/or overlooking the effect of obesity in their analyses [21-26]. From a clinical standpoint, determining whom to screen for OSA can be challenging in AF patients who have normal body habitus and otherwise without sleep related symptoms. Hence, we sought to investigate whether an association between OSA and AF differs by obesity diagnosis.
METHODS
Subjects and Study Design
We retrospectively recruited consecutive patients who were referred to an academic sleep medicine center and who then underwent diagnostic polysomnography (PSG) from April 1, 2013 through June 30, 2017. In all cases, the indication for PSG was for the evaluation of OSA. Inclusion criteria were that age was ≥ 18 years in addition to having full and complete diagnostic data from PSG. All patients with complete PSG data were included in analysis. Those patients with continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) titration or split night studies were not recruited for this study. Patients with primarily central sleep apnea, all of whom had AF, were not included (n = 11).
To augment the number of AF patients in our analysis, we identified patients with AF (April 2013–December 2016) and subsequently selected an equal number of patients without AF (January–June 2017). In other words, these patients were selected in a 1:1 fashion based on AF status. Patient information such as demographics, medical comorbidities, medication prescriptions, and PSG data were acquired from the electronic medical record. Each patient’s history was independently reviewed by a clinician for verification of data in order to identify discrepancies. AF was diagnosed by International Classification of Diseases-10 coding (I48.0, I48.1, I48.11, I48.19, I48.2, I48.20, I48.21, I48.91, Z86.79) in the electronic medical record. We then reviewed electrocardiograms and clinic notes to confirm the accuracy of AF diagnosis. The diagnosis of AF was not based on electrocardiograms obtained during the PSG. Age was stratified by older vs. younger, according to the median age of the cohort. Obesity was defined as body mass index (BMI) ≥ 30 kg/m2. As comorbid HF confounds the association of OSA and AF, effort was made to accurately determine HF status. HF was defined as either left ventricular ejection fraction < 40% or preserved left ventricular ejection fraction with a HF exacerbation as a primary or secondary admission diagnosis. We subsequently confirmed this HF diagnosis by clinician chart review. This study was approved by the University of Virginia Institutional Review Board (IRB 19394).
Sleep Study Data
Overnight PSG was scored under the guidelines put forth by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine [27]. PSGs were first scored by a certified PSG technologist followed by verification by a certified sleep physician. PSG data were managed with Embla Sandman Elite software (Natus Medical Inc., Pleasanton, CA, USA). A standard thermocouple system was used to measure apnea and hypopnea episodes. As per guidelines, apnea was defined as a nasal pressure flow signal reduction of > 90% of the baseline signal that lasted for at least 10 seconds. Hypopnea events were defined as pressure flow signal reductions of > 30% of the baseline that lasted for at least 10 seconds with a ≥ 4% oxygen saturation reduction. The apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) was defined as the number of apnea and hypopnea events divided by the total sleep time. AHI was presented as number of events per hour. OSA was diagnosed with an AHI ≥ 15/hr and severe OSA was diagnosed for AHI ≥ 30/hr.
Statistical Analysis
Baseline characteristics were described for the cohort and then stratified by obesity. Categorical variables were reported as frequencies and percentages and analyzed using the chi-squared test. Continuous data were presented as mean and standard deviation (SD) and analyzed by the t-test. Multivariable logistic regression stratified by obesity was performed to examine the association between AF as the independent variable to OSA or severe OSA as the dependent variable. This design was motivated by the more clinical context where determining whom to screen for OSA in patients with AF is a practical issue (i.e., designating OSA as an outcome in the model) compared to vice-versa. The model was then adjusted for age, male sex, hypertension, obesity, and HF. Analyses were then repeated excluding HF patients. P-values of < 0.05 and alpha values of < 0.05 were statistically significant. These analyses were performed using Statistical Analysis System (SAS) v9.2 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA).
RESULTS
Study population demographics and clinical data are presented in Table 1. Four hundred and fifty-seven patients were included, in which 228 (50%) had AF based on the inclusion of patients in a 1:1 fashion by study design. Of these AF patients, 182 (80%) had paroxysmal AF, while 46 (20%) had persistent or permanent AF. The mean (SD) age of the cohort was 63.1 (13.3) years. The overall mean BMI was 32.2 (8.2) kg/m2, with 216 (47.3%) of the patients being obese. The BMI was similar between those with and without AF [32.1 (7.9) kg/m2 and 32.3 (8.5) kg/m2, respectively; p = 0.82]. Overall, the obese patients tended to be younger, diabetic, and be less male predominant when compared to the non-obese group. More than half of the cohort had OSA [n = 249 (54.5%)], with more than a quarter of patients having severe OSA [n = 127 (27.8%)]. The prevalence of either OSA or severe OSA (i.e., any AHI > 15/hr) was similar between those with and without AF (52.6% vs. 47.4%, respectively; p = 0.24). Stratification of the patients with and without AF by OSA presence and severity is included in Table 2. In non-obese patients, severe OSA was more prevalent in patients with AF compared with those without. However, in obese patients, there was no difference in the prevalence of severe OSA between patients with and without AF (Fig. 1). Overall, the mean AHI was 25.0 ± 23.9/hr and the mean oxygen saturation during PSG was 94.1% ± 2.4%. Male sex was associated with higher AHI. PSG characteristics were similar between the obese and non-obese groups (Table 3).
Patient characteristics stratified by obesity
AF stratified by OSA presence and severity
Comparison of the prevalence of severe OSA between all patients, non-obese patients, and obese patients. There was no difference in the prevalence of severe OSA was observed in all patients and obese patients. In non-obese patients, there was a statistically significant higher prevalence of severe OSA in patients with AF than those without. *p = 0.011. OSA: obstructive sleep apnea, AF: atrial fibrillation.
Sleep study characteristics stratified by obesity
In multivariable analysis, no association was found between AF and any OSA regardless of obesity status (Supplementary Tables 1 and 2 in the online-only Data Supplement). When severe OSA (vs. non-severe OSA) was modeled as a dependent variable, AF was associated with a higher likelihood of severe OSA in non-obese patients [odds ratio (OR) 2.29, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.23–4.35, p = 0.01], but not in obese patients (OR 0.95, 95% CI 0.48–1.90, p = 0.89) (Tables 4 and 5). When excluding those patients with HF, this same pattern of association persisted (Supplementary Tables 3 and 4 in the online-only Data Supplement).
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in non-obese patients
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in obese patients
DISCUSSION
The intent of this study was to examine whether the association of OSA and AF differs by obesity status. In this cohort of sleep clinic patients undergoing PSG, we found that AF was associated with severe OSA, but such an association existed only in the non-obese patients. Specifically, non-obese patients with AF were about two times more likely to have severe OSA. This finding was independent of the confounding factors of age, sex, and HF. This suggests that the association between OSA and AF may be body-habitus dependent. These results do not suggest that obese patients with AF are not at high risk of OSA. In that these patients are obese and by virtue of other comorbidities and factors, they are still at high risk of AF. These results provide an important additional insight into the relationship between obesity, OSA, and AF.
Obesity and OSA share multiple pathophysiological mechanisms, including insulin resistance, hyperleptinemia, endothelial dysfunction, and sympathetic overactivity [28]. They are also associated with the incidence and progression of AF [29,30]. OSA modifies AF via several related mechanisms, with increased sympathetic and vagal tone, hypoxia, and changes in intrathoracic pressure all contributing to AF burden. Therefore, a complex interplay exists between obesity, OSA, and AF [31,32] (Fig. 2). Properly accounting and correcting for the confounding effect of obesity is important in better understanding the relationship between OSA and AF. While it can be addressed by statistical adjustment, residual confounding may persist [33]. In this study, we attempted to address this by stratifying the cohort into two groups by obesity status.
Proposed complex pathophysiology connecting obesity, OSA, and atrial fibrillation. OSA: obstructive sleep apnea.
As anticipated, OSA was highly prevalent in this clinic cohort. When using a more conservative OSA definition, over half of the cohort had OSA and about one-fourth of the cohort had severe OSA. Our hypothesis was that the association of OSA and AF would only exist in non-obese patients as the confounding effect of obesity would be minimized. The results support this assumption, but we found that the association also appears to be limited to severe OSA.
This partly suggests that patients with severe OSA may represent a distinct group from those with non-severe OSA, especially in terms of AF risk. This is consistent with findings from the Sleep Heart Health Study, which established that incidence of nocturnal AF episodes was markedly higher in patients with severe OSA compared to those without OSA (4.8% vs. 0.9%, p = 0.003) [15]. However, since the average BMI was 29 kg/m2 in that study, which is similar to the cut off value used in our study to determine the non-obese group vs. obese group and the results by body habitus was not shown, direct comparison with our study is not feasible. Cadby et al. [34] followed 6841 sleep clinic patients a median 11.9 years and determined that OSA (defined as AHI ≥ 5/hr) was an independent predictor of hospital admission for incident AF [hazard ratio (HR) 1.55, 95% CI 1.21–2.00]. Those with severe OSA (defined as AHI ≥ 30/hr) had even a higher incidence of AF (HR 1.73, 95% CI 1.29–2.33). As such, the association of OSA and AF may be limited to severe OSA.
The findings of our current study are consistent with the Stevenson et al. [35] study, which prospectively enrolled 90 patients with paroxysmal or persistent AF matched to 45 controls who both subsequently underwent diagnostic PSG. The prevalence of OSA (AHI > 15/hr) was greater in the AF group with subsequent multivariable analysis demonstrating an association between the two (OR 3.04). The patient population was largely non-obese, with a weighted mean BMI of approximately 27.5 kg/m2 and was without traditional risk factors for OSA. Yet, we are unable to directly cross examine our findings in majority of other studies as, despite controlling for BMI, the interaction of OSA and body habitus in the relationship with AF has not typically been considered in their analyses. Lin et al. [24] in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis demonstrated conflicting results that physician diagnosed OSA was associated with incident AF people with obesity (BMI > 30 kg/m2) (OR 2.73, 95% CI 1.33–5.60), but not in people without obesity. However, non-obesity was not associated with incident AF (OR 1.04, 95% CI 0.41–2.59). The reason might be partly due to the fact that they used the physician-diagnosed OSA rather than screening entire cohort with PSG. Their results were also obtained from a multiethnic general population with relatively low risk for OSA and might not be appropriately translated to our results using clinic-based participants with multiple OSA risk factors.
Still, the absence of significant association between OSA and AF may have resulted from additional unmeasured or unidentified confounding variables may have nullified or altered the association in the obese. Most of the patients with OSA or severe OSA did not have AF, but a significant portion of patients with AF had OSA or severe OSA.
There is some suggestion that non-obese patients with OSA have a different clinical phenotype than the obese population [36]. Non-obese patients seem to have a lower threshold for respiratory arousal, leading to a higher measured AHI, and they also seem to have higher rates of altered craniofacial anatomy, including a larger soft palate and smaller anterior-posterior dimensions of the naso- and oropharynx [37]. This finding may be particularly pertinent to Asian populations whose body habitus is typically non-obese yet has a higher prevalence of OSA. Our study findings may prompt a clinician to consider the risk of OSA even among non-obese AF patients. Further, this may support the notion that screening for OSA by diagnostic PSG may be warranted in all AF patients, regardless of body habitus or perceived risk. With the more widespread use of home PSG and improved methods of AF detection, we anticipate that there would be more opportunities to further verify our findings and examine the implications of this finding in the context of future outcomes.
A strength of our study includes the individual review of each chart by a clinician for confirmation of AF status, clinically-relevant HF, and medication prescriptions. This increases the fidelity of the extracted data. Several limitations need to be considered in our study. Our study suffers from selection bias given that only referred patients were included. However, this bias exists for both cases and controls. This study is also unable to infer any causal relationship between OSA and AF in non-obese patients, despite finding an association between the two. Approximately one-third of those with AF are asymptomatic, suggesting that some patients within the no-AF cohort likely had subclinical AF [13]. The true burden of AF is difficult to assess without repeated and/or continuous rhythm monitoring. It is also possible that the degree of AF burden and severity of OSA have an interaction that was not feasible to investigate in this study. Data regarding the use of CPAP prior to the diagnostic PSG in those patients undergoing re-evaluation of their OSA was not available in our study. Despite the lack of evidence supporting the effect of CPAP on the primary prevention of AF, the results in our study may have been affected by CPAP therapy, which was not considered in our study. The AHI criteria (AHI 15) used in this study to define OSA may have been overly strict. However, such cut off value is frequently adopted in both clinical and research settings [38].
Conclusion
In conclusion, in patients with high risk AF, the independent association of AF with OSA was present only in the non-obese, and such an association was limited to patients with severe OSA. In contrast, no association between AF and OSA was found in obese patients regardless of the OSA severity. This suggests that the association between AF and OSA is partly dependent on body habitus.
Supplementary Materials
The online-only Data Supplement is available with this article at https://doi.org/10.17241/smr.2021.00857.
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in non-obese patients
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in obese patients
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in non-obese patients (excluding heart failure patients)
Multivariable analyses of predictors of severe obstructive sleep apnea in obese patients (excluding heart failure patients)
Acknowledgments
This work was partly supported by the George Beller Award (Heart and Vascular Institute of University of Virginia) and NIH under grant R21HL140432 and R21HL150502 (YK).
Notes
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest.
Authors’ Contribution
Conceptualization: Stafford PL, Kwon Y. Data curation: Stafford PL, Harmon EK, Patel P, Walker M. Formal analysis: Stafford PL, Kwon Y, Bilchick K. Funding acquisition: Kwon Y. Investigation: Stafford PL, Kwon Y, Harmon EK, Patel P, Walker M, Bilchick K. Methodology: Stafford PL, Kwon Y, Mazimba S. Project administration: Kwon Y. Resources: Kwon Y, Mazimba S, Bilchick K. Software: Kwon Y, Mazimba S, Bilchick K. Supervision: Kwon Y, Mazimba S, Bilchick K, Mehta NK. Validation: Lin GM, Park SJ, Chatterjee NA, Mehta NK. Visualization: Stafford PL, Kwon Y. Writing—original draft: Stafford PL, Kwon Y. Writing—review & editing: all authors.